My great, sighing discontent with the library

Every time I walk into my local library, I heave a sigh of discontent because it has very few books. But books are knowledge and ideas, and that’s what libraries are for.

Libraries ain’t what they used to be.

I was raised in a small city in Western Victoria. The library was a regular in our week, and my first library card was an enormous excitement to me. I spent a vast amount of my childhood and my youth in the library, as I steadily read through everything that was available.

I remember skulking about among the shelves, watching in awe as people far, far older than me walked confidently into the Reference Section, and sat down importantly, reading Much More Difficult Things Than I Could.

I imagined myself much older, myself able to navigate the mysterious riches of the Reference Section, and I often dreamed about being a scholarly type, who had to use giant books, write great swathes of notes, and eventually produce something spectacular that others could read. Also in the Reference Section.

I would skulk past the adult fiction, eyeballing the covers, and wondering if I was game enough to borrow them and read them. Some were clearly not for me. Others looked terrifying. But they were all deeply fascinating.

Fast foward thirty years, and the libraries have changed.

There are no reference sections any more.

There are computers, games, kids activities, magazines, cafes. There are board games, people sitting around talking on phones, playing with Lego. They’re noisy; oh! So, so noisy.

The library is now a community centre, not a place of ideas and knowledge.

Libraries have become drop-in centres. In principle I don’t mind this at all; they are now beating hearts where before they were quiet little places that many active people dreaded to approach. They bring together community, in a way that community centres still do, but the libraries are often closer to commercial hubs than are community centres

I don’t understand why there are no books. Libraries should have books. Right?

What I am missing are the books. The volume of books in libraries here in South Australia has appeared to have decreased so drastically that it is even difficult to get your hands on classic literature. Additionally, it is almost impossible to obtain any key business titles; in fact, I have had to purchase almost every title of any value to my own business over the past sixteen years, and that’s because I couldn’t borrow them. I recently purchased two extensive and highly recommended bibliographies of tried-and-tested, loved children’s books – Honey for a Child’s Heart and Books Children Love; and when searching for the titles, found that perhaps one in ten is even held by any library in South Australia.

Where have all the books gone?

Why do the libraries have shelves of books they’re getting rid of, and are not replacing them with anything useful? They’re filled with all kinds of ideological rubbish, but the classics are gone. Gone, gone, gone.

It baffles me that great literature is no longer available in the library system. In my bafflement, I am roundly discontented. I cannot borrow literature, but I can borrow books that tell my child that being a stripper is a great thing to be. I cannot borrow literature, or even find useful books about key historical moments in time, but I can borrow books like Deadly Science, which totally confuses young kids. (The word deadly in this particular title is an Aboriginal English word meaning “awesome”, which is fine except that in the context almost all other children see ‘science’, look at the cover with starfish on it, and think ‘deadly’ means ‘things that will kill me’.)

Why can I borrow Disney’s versions of classic literature, but not the originals? Why do I have to wade through videos, technology, and books about games and TV shows to find what might be useful? And why, when I go to the ‘science’ section are there are only 20 books, and not one of them is about lizards?

There is something profoundly broken about a world that does not freely share knowledge and ideas.

There seems to be an expectation that everyone is functioning digitally. And yet we know that keeping children off screens, away from digital products is what we need to be doing. Libraries now are ditching physical books in favour of ebooks, audiobooks that are only available on a smartphone app, tablets, games, and screen-based technology, when what we need is more access to physical books!

It is entirely possible to read books aloud to your child from a phone. I know that. But digital books are so easily manipulated that you can’t be sure that you’re getting an edition that hasn’t been tampered with. Additionally, introducing a smartphone into any activity with a child is just asking for trouble. Anyone running a library ought to know this, and ought to know that preferencing a hardcopy book, in the great Dissolving of Brains Inside Digital Environs Age, is to be prioritised.

While it might seem on the surface that enabling libraries to function as drop-in centres is a good idea, what happens is that the library soon needs more space for people to come in and play. Or talk. Or whatever. But that is not the purpose of a library. The purpose of a library is to house ideas and knowledge, and to make those freely available to the public. If the public is not capable of entering such a place, it will go elsewhere; and that is ok.

Not everyone is drawn to a library.

Not everyone wants to take their kids to the library.

But for those of us who do, we need to be able to get the things that libraries house. Books. Knowledge. Ideas. Unfortunately, this is no longer possible. Libraries are instead facilitating the individual purchase of items for personal libraries at home, because they simply do not make titles available. They don’t accept donations of titles, either. So when everyone who is buying books wants to donate them somewhere, they will end up in the bin.

In an age in which we are having to face choices about what robots can and can’t do for us, few things are as worrying as when knowledge and ideas end up in the bin. Instead of going to the source, people will go to a robot that was ‘trained’ on the source, and programmed with a particular perspective.

I don’t need to tell you what happens next. Do I?

xx Leticia

Get more like this in Lightbulb Moments

Ideas, thinking, and tips for better freelance business. Sent (most) Mondays. Are you in?

What's on your mind now?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.